Magic Bullet vs. NutriBullet: Who’s the Winner?

So how do you choose between the Magic Bullet vs. NutriBullet? 

They are similar in some ways yet different in others.  The answer depends on several factors such as: price, motor speed, cup size and accessories to name a few.  Either the Magic Bullet or NutriBullet will make a great addition to your kitchen.

However, there are some distinct differences between the two that we’ll cover in this article. By comparing and contrasting these blenders in detail, we hope to help you find the best blender for your needs.  If you’d like to compare more blenders before making a final decision, check out our other blender review below.

Recommended Reading: Best Single Serve Blenders

Bullet Blender Comparison Table

Specs	Magic Bullet	NutriBullet
Power	250 watts	600 watts
Size	4¾” diameter x 12” height	5.375" diameter x 15" height
Base Weight	2.3 pounds	4 pounds
Capacity	Up to 18 oz	Up to 24 oz
Warranty	1 year limited, can pay to extend for 4 more years	1 year limited, can pay to extend for 4 more years
Plastic	BPA Free	BPA Free
Speed	20,000 RPM	21,500 RPM
Components	1 High-Torque Power Base, 1 Stainless Steel Cross Blade, 1 Stainless Steel Flat Blade, 1 Tall Cup, 1 Short Cup, 4 Party Mugs, 4 Colored Lip Rings, 2 Stay-Fresh Re-sealable Lids, 2 Shaker-Steamer Tops, 1 10-second Recipe Book	1 High-Torque Power Base, 1 Extractor Blade, 1 Milling Blade, 1 Tall Cup, 2 Short Cups, 1 Handled Lip Ring, 1 Regular Lip Ring, 2 Stay-fresh Resealable Lids, 1 User Manual & Cookbook, 1 Pocket Nutritionist
Cleanup	Top-shelf dishwasher safe parts	Top-shelf dishwasher safe parts

Magic Bullet vs. NutriBullet Review 2024

We’ll be looking at these products side by side to compare the advantages and disadvantages of each.  Our review will outline details like: ease of use, special features, warranty information, product dimensions along with clean up and ideal recipes.

These two blenders differ in many ways ranging from power to size to price. In this matchup between bullet giants, there’s a clear winner. Read on to find out who we’ve decided takes the prize!

 

1. Magic Bullet 17-Piece Express Mixing Set

 

 

The Magic Bullet is a great option for those looking for a personal blender. It is a versatile choice for those wanting to experiment and make a wide variety of food and drinks in ten seconds or less such as: smoothies, shakes, sauces, soups, salsa, and even omelettes.

You can also chop onions, mince garlic, grind coffee and pulverize spices.  The Magic Bullet also comes with cups and mugs that can be placed in the microwave, refrigerator or freezer if you want to heat or chill your food and drinks.

Wattage

At 250 watts, the magic bullet blender is powerful enough to blend fruits and vegetables. You’ll need to make sure that you add enough liquid to your recipes. The manufacturer suggests adding a half cup of water if you’re planning to include more fibrous vegetables in your smoothie.

Due to the low wattage, this blender is not powerful enough to crush ice though. You can get around this limitation by using softer frozen fruits like bananas and cherries.

Using soft frozen fruit will help cool your smoothie just like ice will but without overworking the motor. But if you’re looking for a blender that will chop ice, the Magic Bullet is likely not the blender for you.

Easy to Use and Store

This blender’s assembled dimensions including the tall cup are a compact 4.75″ diameter X 12″ height. Its base weighs just 2.3 pounds, though its shipping weight is a bit higher at 6.23 pounds. It is small enough to stay out on your countertop even if you have a small-sized kitchen. It also packs away easily in small cabinets.  

You’ll find that when it’s time to take out your Magic Bullet, it’s a speedy process. It’s as simple as adding your ingredients to the cup of your choice, twisting on the blade, and setting the bullet onto the power base. Lastly, you just press down and twist to get started.  There are no buttons to press which makes it super easy to use.

When you’re done making smoothies, for example, you can twist on the comfort ring to make it easy to drink straight from the cup.  Here’s a quick video that shows the blending process in action.

This product comes with 17 pieces. For instance, you get a short cup, a tall cup and four party mugs so you can vary the amounts of the recipes you’re making. The mugs come with lids so you can easily take your healthy, nutrient-packed smoothie with you if you’re on the go.

The maximum pitcher capacity is 18 ounces. It’s the perfect size to pack several different types of ingredients in for a nutritious drink. For example, this delicious green smoothie recipe is a super healthy on the go drink you can create in just minutes.

You’ll find it’s hard to get a lot of variety packed into the smaller 8-ounce cup. This small size will work great if you want to make a quick dip for veggies, grind spices or coffee beans, or just make a protein powder shake.  

Along with the blender, you get the 10 second recipe book which gives you an amazing variety of recipes to try out. You’ll never get bored. This book makes it easy to create healthy meals and snacks quickly and easily.

For instance, you can make guacamole, egg salad, bean dip, coconut coffee, and even baby food. You’ll have so many ways to experiment with your magic bullet right out of the box.

Smoothies, Soups, Snacks & More

This blender is ideal for people who are looking for a bullet blender that will make single servings quickly. If you’re looking to make pre and postworkout smoothies, soups, or quick dips for snacks, this blender is a great choice.

You can also use the magic bullet to grind spices to keep in your spice organizer rack. If you’re looking for an appliance to quickly pulverize small seeds like flax or cumin, this product will work great in a pinch. If you’re grinding larger seeds, stick with a dedicated spice grinder like one of these here.

This blender is not so ideal if you’re looking for a product that will crush ice or emulsify the really tough fibrous parts of vegetables like kale stems, cabbage, or broccoli stems.

You’ll also want to be choosy about what frozen ingredients you use. Since the motor is only 250 watts, you’ll find that even frozen strawberries are difficult to blend.  

Motor Power

The instruction manual notes that you should not run this motor for more than 60 seconds at a time. For this reason, we do not recommend this blender if you want to make recipes like hummus that require a longer blend time.

This product struggles to make hummus because chickpea skins are tough for it to blend. Overuse can easily burn out this relatively lower powered motor.  

It’s best to stick with soft fruits and vegetables  if you choose this product. You’ll still have plenty of delicious options to drink and eat using just these ingredients.

You also can’t go wrong making a peanut butter based smoothie in the Magic Bullet. In fact, you can even use it to make peanut butter from scratch.  

Overall, if you’re looking for a blender to make quick and simple food and drinks, this is a solid choice.

Parts and Warranty

The Magic Bullet comes with a 1-year free limited warranty. The manufacturer guarantees that the product will be free of defects caused by the manufacturer for a full year. They will cover replacement parts or a replacement blender if the product stops working to your satisfaction due to defects in the materials or workmanship.  

They will not cover shipping and handling for replacement products or parts. Be prepared to pay for that cost if you have to take advantage of this warranty. This product will also not be covered under warranty for problems that occur due to misuse. In addition, you can extend this limited warranty for four years for an additional fee.

You’ll find that if you need to order new parts yourself, it’s easy to do so online. An advantage of the Magic Bullet is that there is simply one style: “The Original.”

You can quickly find replacement cups if yours happen to break or you find that you want extra cups handy.  Another convenience is that the cups and mugs are both microwave and freezer safe.

Cleaning this blender is easy too.  The Magic Bullet is dishwasher friendly. Of course, the motor is not dishwasher safe but the rest of the parts are. You can also handwash it if you prefer.

Summary

This blender is ideal for those looking to purchase one appliance to handle multiple tasks. The Magic Bullet replaces a blender, food processor and coffee grinder.

It makes a great option for small apartment kitchens and users not looking to serve a family. If you’re looking for a high powered blender to serve large quantities, then this product is not the right fit for you.  You should read our review below of high performing, larger blenders then.

Recommended Reading: The Best Alternatives to Vitamix

The Magic Bullet is also ideal for those looking to try out smoothie making for the first time. It’s a respected, simple to use brand that keeps its instructions straightforward. You can experiment with all kinds of recipes in this convenient blender.

Check Price on Amazon

 

2. NutriBullet 12-Piece High-Speed Blender/Mixer System(600Watts)

 

 

This blender is well-known as the “Original Nutrient Extractor”. The NutriBullet’s exclusive extractor technology uses a powerful 600 watt motor with cyclonic action and its extractor blades are patented.

The purpose of the nutrient extractor is to break down the cell walls of plant foods unlike other blenders and juicers. By doing so, many essential minerals and vitamins contained within the plant are released.

This process allows your body to absorb the most nutrition from your food. So when you’re making smoothies containing fruits and vegetables, the NutriBullet easily blends them into a silky, nutrient-rich drink that your body can easily digest.

There’s a cookbook and a pocket nutritionist manual included so you can create nutrient-packed recipes in seconds for the whole family. You can also download a recipe app to your mobile device for added convenience.

Wattage

At 600 watts, this motor is much more powerful than the Magic Bullet. Your smoothies will have a silkier, smoother texture than using the Magic Bullet.  

With its high powered motor, you’ll be able to benefit from the nutrients in hard to break down ingredients like nuts. This blender can  pulverize tough fruits and vegetables and even break through fibrous stalks.  It can also handle crushed ice from the freezer but not large ice cubes.

Easy to Use and Store

The dimensions of this blender are 5.375″ in diameter x 15″ height.  Its base weighs just 3.6 pounds. You can leave it out on your counter for easy access. Like the Magic Bullet, it packs away nicely in small cabinets.  

This product comes with 12 pieces. For instance, you get two short cups, a tall cup and two stay fresh re-sealable lids. A cookbook and user manual along with a pocket nutritionist are also included. So it’s perfect if you’re into healthy eating.

There’s a great suction cup locking mechanism with the NutriBullet. This feature keeps it from shaking too much on your counter while you’re blending.

However, you must be aware that the suction cups on this blender can get stuck to the counter if left out. A tip to get around this is to slide a cork trivet underneath the blender when it’s not in use.  

The large cup holds up to 24 ounces. It will let you make a big batch of smoothies, soups, salsas and more so you can share with your whole family. It’s easy to use too.

You simply add the ingredients to the cup, twist on the blade and set the cup with blade onto the power base, just like the Magic Bullet. Here’s a video that shows you how easy the NutriBullet is to use.

Parts and Warranty

The NutriBullet comes with a free 1-year limited warranty. The manufacturer guarantees for a full year that the product will be free of any defects caused by the manufacturer.

You can pay to extend this limited warranty for four more years if you want. For as long as you have the limited warranty, the manufacturer will cover the cost of replacing defective parts or the whole product.  

They will not cover shipping and handling for replacements. As with the Magic Bullet, your product also won’t be covered if your issue was caused by misuse.

Operation & Clean Up

The NutriBullet motor runs more quietly than other blenders. You can blend your morning smoothie and not worry so much about the noise which is an added benefit.  

The parts are also easy to clean. Your blades will rinse off with soap and water, and you can put the cups in the top rack of your dishwasher. If you choose to hand wash, you might find that the cups are a bit small to get your hand in.  Therefore, you’ll need to use a brush to make this task easier.

Summary

The NutriBullet is another respected and well-liked blender. It’s perfect if you’re looking for a blender that will handle harder and tougher ingredients like frozen fruit, fibrous vegetable stalks and ice.

You’ll be able to make single serve smoothies or make several servings at once with the larger cup. This blender is great for those who want more capacity and power than the Magic Bullet. 

Overall, the NutriBullet is a sturdy blender that’s great for making shakes, smoothies, sauces, soups and more for the whole family. You’ll also have tons of healthy recipe options to try between the books and the app.

Check Price on Amazon

 

Magic Bullet versus NutriBullet Buyer’s Guide

The blender has come a long way in its nearly century-old history. First dreamed up in 1922 by Stephen Poplawski, it was created to mix up malts and milkshakes in the old soda fountains.

Nowadays, people often purchase blenders as a way to make healthy eating easy. Either the Magic Bullet or the NutriBullet will help you accomplish this goal.  

 Who’s the Winner?

It’s hard to choose the best bullet blender between these two well-known brands. They share a lot of similarities in terms of size and function. Either of these bullet blenders will do the job to make you a delicious healthy smoothie along with other foods.

But when it comes down to it, we believe the NutriBullet is the clear winner between these two because of its higher powered motor, higher capacity, nutrient extraction capabilities and speed.

Power and Blades

The Magic Bullet and the NutriBullet both come with two blades. While both will effectively blend your smoothies, the NutriBullet’s patented extractor blades will give you a smoother texture than the Magic Bullet. The NutriBullet also comes with a specialized milling blade made to blend oats, nuts, and spices. 

The Magic Bullet, at only 250 watts, simply cannot handle the harder, tougher ingredients. The NutriBullet is able to blend medium-sized ice, frozen fruit, seeds, nuts and harder vegetables with its 600 watt motor. It is the clear winner in this category.  

Size and Storage

The Magic Bullet and NutriBullet are comparable in terms of parts and size. Both require approximately the same amount of storage space in your cabinet.  

The NutriBullet is taller but we think it wins this category because of its larger, 24-ounce cup capacity. If you want the smallest bullet blender, choose the Magic Bullet.

Warranty

Both of these bullet blenders come with a free 1-year limited warranty. Each warranty requires the owner to pay shipping and handling, though the replacements provided are for free.

We like that both blenders give you the option to extend this warranty for up to 4 years after the end of that first year. However, this extended warranty costs extra.  

Recipe Books 

The Magic Bullet’s 10-second recipe book is a speedy way to make healthy recipes. The NutriBullet’s user manual, cookbook, pocket nutritionist and app offer many ways to create healthy foods, drinks and snacks as well as get nutritional information.  In this category, we think that the clear winner is NutriBullet. 

Budget

Both of these options are relatively inexpensive when compared to larger blenders. But if you’re looking for the lowest cost option between the two, the NutriBullet system is less expensive. However, it comes with only 12 pieces vs. the Magic Bullet’s 17.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

 

Q: Which is better: Magic Bullet or NutriBullet?  

A: We believe the NutriBullet is the better choice overall. It is a higher quality product. The NutriBullet has: a more powerful yet quieter motor, higher capacity, more nutrition info/recipes, and nutrient extraction technology. The NutriBullet is a premium product that will serve you well.

 

Q: Are the Magic Bullet and NutriBullet cups the same?  

A: No, the cups from these bullet blenders cannot be used interchangeably. However, the 32-ounce capacity cup from the NutriBullet Pro 900 set seems to work with the basic NutriBullet.    

 

Q: Is the Magic Bullet made by NutriBullet?  

A: No, neither of these products are made by the other. Both products are made by a company called Homeland Housewares.

 

Conclusion

The NutriBullet is our winner for the best bullet blender. It’s a high quality, great performing blender that makes a variety of foods and drinks quickly and easily.  However, the Magic Bullet is still a great option. 

When you choose the best bullet blender for your kitchen, keep in mind your preference for power, capacity, speed and size. 

We hope that after reading our detailed Magic Bullet vs. NutriBullet reviews and comprehensive buying guide, you’ll have all the information you need to select the best bullet blender for your needs.

We’ve chosen our winner—now it’s time to choose yours!